Speaking directly to a manager when calling in sick can help employers understand what support a member of staff needs – but businesses should be careful not to turn the process into an additional source of stress for employees who are unwell.
That is the message from HR software provider BrightHR, which says conversations between managers and employees should normally form part of the sickness absence process, while recognising that a phone call will not always be appropriate.
The comments follow remarks by Sir Charlie Mayfield, former chairman of John Lewis, who was reported in The Times calling for employees to contact their managers directly when they are unable to work because of illness.
While direct communication can allow managers to establish immediate practical needs, arrange cover and make sure appropriate support is available, BrightHR says employers also need to recognise circumstances where speaking on the phone could create a genuine barrier.
For organisations focused on workplace wellbeing, the issue highlights the importance of balancing effective absence management with compassion for employees at a time when they may be physically or mentally unwell.
Alan Price, CEO at BrightHR, said:
“I agree with Sir Charlie about the value of a direct conversation when an employee is off sick. Speaking to a manager helps both sides understand what’s needed, whether that’s arranging cover, discussing workload or making sure the employee has the right support.
“However, employers need to apply common sense. There will be situations where a phone call isn’t practical or appropriate, for example where someone is seriously unwell, receiving hospital treatment, has a disability that makes phone communication difficult, or is experiencing a mental health condition that makes a call particularly challenging.
“In those circumstances, employers should be prepared to make reasonable adjustments and consider other appropriate ways for the employee to report their absence.”
Creating A Supportive Sickness Absence Culture
How an organisation responds when somebody reports sick can influence the wider relationship between employees and their managers.
A supportive conversation can provide reassurance and give an employee an opportunity to explain whether they need adjustments or additional help. An overly rigid or confrontational approach, however, risks making an already difficult situation more stressful.
Managers therefore have an important role to play in ensuring absence conversations remain focused on practicalities and employee welfare rather than making workers feel they have to justify being ill.
Clear workplace policies can also help remove uncertainty. Employees should understand who they need to contact, how quickly they are expected to report an absence and what alternative arrangements are available if they are unable to communicate in the usual way.
Flexibility Can Be Important For Employee Wellbeing
Employers also need to consider individual circumstances rather than assuming one method of reporting sickness will work for everyone.
Someone experiencing severe physical symptoms may simply be unable to hold a telephone conversation, while an employee experiencing anxiety or another mental health difficulty could find a mandatory call particularly challenging.
Disabilities and communication needs may also require employers to adapt their usual procedures.
BrightHR’s comments suggest that direct manager contact can remain a useful part of absence management, provided organisations retain enough flexibility to respond appropriately when circumstances require a different approach.
Ultimately, sickness reporting is not simply an administrative exercise. Done well, it can be an opportunity for managers to demonstrate that employee wellbeing is taken seriously, while ensuring teams have the information they need to manage an unexpected absence.
For employers, the challenge is therefore to create procedures that encourage clear communication without losing sight of the person who is unwell.
