Is it ever OK for Doctors to lie?

The Hippocratic Oath is often summarised by the Latin ‘Primum non nocere’ which translates as ‘First do no harm’. But is it ever OK for doctors to lie if they do so in the best interests of their patient?

There are many circumstances where it might be tempting for doctors to lie. Just a few examples include:

  • To delay delivering bad news that will cause extreme emotional distress
  • To avoid breaching confidentiality when talking about a friend or family member
  • To circumvent giving the patient information of little or no value to them

However, patients who have been lied to are very likely to feel aggrieved if they find out information about their medical condition or treatment has been withheld from them.

In some cases, third parties such as next of kin may also raise a dispute if they discover they were not told the full severity of a loved one’s condition and believe they may have been able to provide better support if they had been made aware.

 

The Duty of Candour

A specific professional commitment to tell the truth is the Duty of Candour, which requires doctors to inform their patients when something has gone wrong with their medical care.

In January 2020, Peter Walsh, the chief executive of Action against Medical Accidents, wrote a guest blog for the Professional Standards Authority for Health and Social Care in which he called the Duty of Candour “the biggest and most overdue advance in patients’ rights and patient safety that we have ever seen”.

This statutory duty was introduced in England in late 2014, partly in response to the Mid Staffordshire public inquiry, in which it emerged that NHS organisations were not required by law to reveal incidents that led to harm or even death of patients.

Mr Walsh wrote: “The system had frowned on cover-ups, but had not been prepared to do anything serious to stop them, and continued to tolerate them until public pressure became unbearable.”

While the Duty of Candour aims to prevent cover-ups, rather than to punish those responsible, Mr Walsh added that the Care Quality Commission has so far been “pretty woeful” in regulating the duty and holding anyone to account.

 

Candour and Fitness to Practise

Telling the truth when something goes wrong goes to the heart of GMC Fitness to Practise hearings, particularly in the case of R v Ghosh (1982) which is widely quoted by FTP panels.

On appeal, the court introduced an important two-factor test of dishonesty:

  • Was the individual objectively dishonest by ordinary decent standards?
  • Did the individual consider their actions dishonest by their own standards?

Combining the objective and subjective elements into a single legal definition of dishonesty can be applied across all areas of professional misconduct, from issues of disrepute, to cases where patient care is directly impacted.

Importantly, just because a doctor is found to have acted dishonestly, it does not necessarily mean that their Fitness to Practise has also been impaired, and the two should not be conflated during hearings.

GMC solicitors can successfully appeal against sanctions imposed in this way, to reverse suspensions and to avoid referrals to professional regulatory bodies.

 

Why does the truth matter?

The value of the truth is more than just ethical. It may seem simple to say that patients and regulators should always be told the truth, or in practice to argue that telling the truth would only ‘open a can of worms’.

However, the truth is a tool to understand where mistakes have been made and to ensure that those mistakes are not made again in future.

It can also hold to account those individuals whose actions were deliberately harmful, or where harm occurred due to a lack of ability; similarly, the truth can vindicate those who acted to the required professional standards, in an incident that unavoidably led to patient harm.

Doctors and GMC solicitors share a duty to tell the truth and to meet strict standards of professionalism, and should be able to feel supported by their employers and regulators when doing so.

Crucially, a sensitive apology should not be considered an admission of guilt or a tool to apportion blame, but rather as a way to recognise that – for whatever reason – something has gone wrong.

 

Moving on from candour

Finally, candour can bring about a sense of closure, or at least a milestone to mark the point where harm ends, and healing begins.

By informing the patient of what has happened, you create that milestone and provide them with the facts they need to start psychologically processing the event and recovering from the negative impacts – both physical and emotional – of their experiences.

In many cases, patients will respond positively to this when it is handled with care, and may even appreciate the extra support offered to them, rather than feeling misled by those tasked with taking care of them.

 

About Lisa Baker, Editor, Wellbeing News 4936 Articles
Editor Lisa Baker is a professional writer and the owner of Need to See IT Publishing. However, Lisa is also passionate about the benefits of a holistic approach to healing, being a qualified Vibrational Therapist. Lisa also has qualifications in Auricular Therapy, Massage, Kinesiology, Crystal Healing, Seichem and is a Reiki Master.